Tina Rapp

Writer

  • Blog
  • Creative work
    • Essays
    • Poetry
    • Articles
    • Film and Video
    • Fiction
  • Commercial Work
  • About
  • Contact

The intersection of hope

December 31, 2016 by Tina Rapp in ~Culture mesh~

Katrina Kenison writes about the gifts of ordinary days. I enjoy her gentle, probing work, which often centers on the simple pleasures of life. Her focus is on gratitude for our everyday experiences, the ones that virtually all of us can share: sunsets, walks in nature, a home-cooked meal.

Her recent post, "joy, tempered," reflected on the particular joys of the holiday season: twinkling lights, a walk through new-fallen snow, chopping apricots for Christmas cookies. She talked about this year's holiday delights being intertwined with a persistent sense of loss. More than a month after the U.S. presidential election, she admits to grappling with "the profound disconnect between our President elect's values and my own."

She tapped into a sense of helplessness that many of us feel. I know many people who can't bear to follow the news because it's so disturbing to hear the contentious messages that Trump posts on his Twitter feed. Others feel a need to stay informed, but don't know how to speak up when Trump's words and actions veer dangerously close to gutting the ideals that have made America great: civil discourse, a fair and free press, and free speech, among them.

Kenison's post was not a screed. It was not a denial of our president-elect's rightful election. It simply acknowledged a vastly different value system that Trump represents and the sadness that the incoming administration produces in those of us who see these times as those in which, as Kenison neatly sums up, "the civic values, freedoms, and precepts we once took for granted are threatened." 

She offered her thoughts with the hope that we can honor our differences and share them with compassion and understanding. I, too, struggle with how to come to terms with Trump's brazen provocations on social media (nuclear escalation, anyone?) and his inability to embrace the diversity of all Americans, not just the ones he caters to on his thank-you tours. Kenison's careful, reasoned words helped sort through these emotions, offering an olive branch of healing based on an honest discussion of ethical and moral values.

Her blog's "Comments" section proved that not everyone was interested in sharing an open dialogue. Most comments offered thanks for her words; they honored the intent in which she offered them. However, the dissenters told her not to write about politics. Some announced their plans to unsubscribe to her blog because of her political views. 

One comment from a Trump supporter caught my eye in particular. It read, "A stronger military, jobs for those who simply wish to put a roof over their children's heads and put food on the table, or even have affordable insurance to care for sick children....these are not bad things [and why I voted for Trump]."

These words made me stop in my tracks. What makes this Trump supporter think these aren't shared beliefs? 

I'm willing to wager that the vast majority of Americans share these desires, regardless of who they voted for or which political party they support. If we'd talk more with each other, instead of isolating ourselves from one another, we'd know that. Hillary Clinton was as hawkish a candidate as any in 2016. She had the backing of many military generals. I don't think there is any doubt that she would have promoted a stronger military.

There's also no question that President Obama made it a top priority to help Americans put (and keep) a roof over our children's heads and put food on our tables. How? By shepherding us past the great recession with historically low mortgage rates and consistently lowered unemployment rates. While I believe we must accept globalization and automation as part of our economic reality and take personal responsibility to find jobs in this new economy, Trump voters seem to believe that nationalism and corporate welfare are needed to put people back to work in old-era jobs. So let's talk about these diverging views, not make false accusations about each other's motives.

Of course, we all want affordable health insurance to care for our children. But the healthcare system has been broken for decades, long before Obamacare was enacted to promote healthcare for everyone. About 20 years ago, my family was dumped from its health insurance plan with 30 days notice and a premium increase of more than 100 percent. We couldn't afford the new rates and were forced to scramble to find an alternative. Premiums have gone up and benefits have gone down ever since. I believe that the medical/health insurance/pharmaceutical ecosystem holds us all hostage to its unrealistically high costs. A repeal-and-replace Obamacare strategy won't solve this core problem. Others disagree; so let's talk about these differences.

But how, exactly, do we start a dialogue that is based on the similar experiences and hopes we share? And still discuss the root issues and real-world solutions that we disagree on?

I'm going to subscribe to Katrina Kenison's blog for starters. Not because she feels the way I do or voted the way I did, but because she carefully describes her feelings without anger or blame. She helps me understand the deep-seated issues that many Americans are grappling with and that people of all political persuasions should be able to discuss. These are the messages we need to share. Not of right or wrong; good or evil; winners or losers. 

The way forward likely starts with us agreeing on the basic tenets of an America that works for everyone. Yes, this includes a stronger military, a chicken in every pot, and affordable healthcare for all. One side cannot claim these hopes as their own and disparage the rest of us because we don't agree on which policies can deliver these benefits to the American people.

If we are willing to listen, to discuss, to care about all Americans and their experiences and ideas, we might have a chance to settle on common ground and move forward with civility. It's time to subscribe to others' voices, not unsubscribe. It may be the only chance we've got.

 

December 31, 2016 /Tina Rapp
civil discourse, Trump era, hope
~Culture mesh~
1 Comment

  • ~Culture mesh~ 34
    • Feb 23, 2019 The divide, Hollywood style   Feb 23, 2019
    • Aug 30, 2018 Why John McCain’s loss feels personal Aug 30, 2018
    • Jul 31, 2018 What Gate 35X can teach us about chaotic times Jul 31, 2018
    • Jun 30, 2018 Is hate the new optimism in America? Jun 30, 2018
    • May 31, 2018 What we say when we don’t talk politics May 31, 2018
    • Apr 30, 2018 Jokes, lies, and tweets in the era of outrage Apr 30, 2018
    • Mar 31, 2018 The phantom thread that binds us Mar 31, 2018
    • Feb 28, 2018 Reverend Graham and the clear view Feb 28, 2018
    • Jan 31, 2018 Finding the end zone in the new America Jan 31, 2018
    • Dec 31, 2017 Fumbling my way into a new year Dec 31, 2017
    • Nov 30, 2017 Corralling the chaos without losing your mind Nov 30, 2017
    • Oct 25, 2017 #MeToo meets the military and it ain't pretty Oct 25, 2017
    • Sep 30, 2017 Oprah and the empathy question Sep 30, 2017
    • Aug 31, 2017 Trump and the ghost of Manny Ramirez Aug 31, 2017
    • Jul 26, 2017 Donald Trump, wonderful man Jul 26, 2017
    • May 31, 2017 The unreliable narrator in the age of Trump May 31, 2017
    • Apr 30, 2017 The love/hate business Apr 30, 2017
    • Mar 31, 2017 Them's fighting words Mar 31, 2017
    • Feb 25, 2017 Dancing while D.C. burns Feb 25, 2017
    • Jan 21, 2017 The audacity of hope, round two Jan 21, 2017
    • Dec 31, 2016 The intersection of hope Dec 31, 2016
    • Nov 30, 2016 Singing my way home Nov 30, 2016
    • Nov 9, 2016 The new American colossus Nov 9, 2016
    • Oct 31, 2016 On rigging an election Oct 31, 2016
    • Aug 31, 2016 When a colonoscopy feels like a day off Aug 31, 2016
    • Jul 25, 2016 It's your reality show, deal with it Jul 25, 2016
    • Apr 25, 2016 Lost and found in Bohemia Apr 25, 2016
    • Mar 22, 2016 A funny thing happened on the way to Facebook Mar 22, 2016
    • Feb 23, 2016 "The Revenant" as chick flick Feb 23, 2016
    • Jan 17, 2016 Citizen Trump: The sequel Jan 17, 2016
    • Nov 23, 2015 Watch your language, Mr. Speaker Nov 23, 2015
    • Sep 28, 2015 It's time to step away from the T-word Sep 28, 2015
    • Aug 30, 2015 Is there a human metric for the workplace? Aug 30, 2015
    • Aug 14, 2015 A day in the life of the New Hampshire primary Aug 14, 2015
  • ~Personal politics~ 3
    • Aug 30, 2018 Why John McCain’s loss feels personal Aug 30, 2018
    • Nov 30, 2017 Corralling the chaos without losing your mind Nov 30, 2017
    • Oct 25, 2017 #MeToo meets the military and it ain't pretty Oct 25, 2017
  • ~Writing~ 11
    • May 31, 2017 The unreliable narrator in the age of Trump May 31, 2017
    • Sep 29, 2016 Everyday triggers that writers can't resist Sep 29, 2016
    • Jun 30, 2016 The scent of cinnamon roses Jun 30, 2016
    • May 31, 2016 Hello, my American idol May 31, 2016
    • Dec 31, 2015 New year, new blog: Four simple steps Dec 31, 2015
    • Oct 31, 2015 Share don't tell: Can you crowdsource storytelling? Oct 31, 2015
    • Sep 14, 2015 Calling all poets: Digital wants you Sep 14, 2015
    • Jul 30, 2015 Eyes wide shut Jul 30, 2015
    • Jul 13, 2015 Rediscovering an endless summer Jul 13, 2015
    • Jun 30, 2015 Re-entry from utopia Jun 30, 2015
    • Jun 18, 2015 What they don't tell you about writing residencies Jun 18, 2015

© Tina Rapp 2015. Keyboard photo credit: Marie Yoho Dorsey. Other photo credits: Tina Rapp, unless otherwise noted.