Tina Rapp

Writer

  • Blog
  • Creative work
    • Essays
    • Poetry
    • Articles
    • Film and Video
    • Fiction
  • Commercial Work
  • About
  • Contact

The unreliable narrator in the age of Trump

May 31, 2017 by Tina Rapp in ~Writing~, ~Culture mesh~

Wayne C. Booth is not a household name, but maybe he should be. A respected author, scholar, and distinguished professor of English at the University of Chicago, Booth's work focused on the art of rhetoric in fiction. As The New York Times summed up in its 2005 obituary of Booth: "[he] illuminated the means by which authors seduce, cajole and more than occasionally lie to their readers in the service of narrative."

His most lasting contribution to the study of rhetoric may be the term "unreliable narrator, " which he coined in his 1961 book The Rhetoric of Fiction (University of Chicago Press). The term quickly took hold as a way to describe a character who may not be credible or trusted, but who shapes how a story is told. 

Unreliable narrators often add drama to a plot and tension to a story line. Does the narrator know the real story, or only parts of it? Does a narrator's upbringing, worldview, or mental health sway the narrative in untrustworthy ways? And how do we know exactly which characters are telling the truth? Whose story can we trust?

An unreliable narrator may be apparent early in a story. Think about Forrest Gump, the narrator whose worldview is so naive that we're not sure we can fully trust him at first. As the story unfolds, we see that while Gump's character may not discern complex truths, he's incapable of dishonesty. His narration simply needs a sort of modern-day translation, which we're only too happy to provide because of his sweet, innocent behavior. We go along happily for the ride once we understand how to perceive this character.

More often, the unreliable narrator suffers from a delusion that is self-inflicted (the alcoholic narrator Rachel in The Girl on the Train) or something more sinister (the villain Keyser Söze in The Usual Suspects). As a dramatic device, these unreliable narrators obfuscate, mislead, and string us along as a story unfolds. They're often revealed at the end of a thriller or mystery so we can enjoy an unexpected twist and a satisfying ending.

Then there are dense narratives filled with unreliable narrators whose purpose is to confuse us as much as possible, all of the time. Films like The Matrix or Memento or the television show Lost are good examples. These stories traffic in continual confusion, packaged as entertainment. There is often no real beginning, middle, or end to the story structure. As soon you think you've found a logical story line, it unravels before you. It's a nonstop rollercoaster of illogical logic.

Fast forward to America in 2017. It's a time in which unreliable narrators have spilled over from fiction into the reality of our everyday lives, a by-product of our post-truth culture. Americans are forced to ask themselves pretty much daily: Who is telling the truth and whose narrative can I trust? Can I trust the media? Our president? A friend's latest post on Facebook?

When unreliable narrators abound in real life, it's not entertaining and it's not a thrill ride. It's confusing and exhausting. There are no neat endings to wrap things up. Our rapid-fire technologies don't help. Social media masquerades as fact-based journalism. Artificial intelligence encroaches on our native human decision making. We've even invented a technology, "virtual reality," to create an alternate world that feels like our real one.

Sure, societies have wrestled with warring narratives and disruptive technologies since the beginning of time. But it seems especially treacherous now, doesn't it? Today, conflicting, continually changing "facts" form a sort of 24/7 entertainment that we can't look away from. These untested, untrusted narratives have previously been the bastion of fiction. But now...

A recent article in The Guardian, "The lying game: why unreliable TV narrators matter in the Trump era," showcases how unreliable narrators have made the leap from fiction to real life in unsettling ways. In this article, writer and director Joe Ahearne talks about the dangers of comparing carefully orchestrated fictional constructs to stories told by politicians in offhanded ways. "Great drama comes from when you have two irreconcilable viewpoints, then there’s a battle and somebody wins. But what’s happening now is that facts seem to be irrelevant. Reality is at stake,” he says.

Is it possible that unreliable narrators could help us both diagnosis and cure our cultural whirlpool of truthiness? Maybe it's time to turn back to Booth for answers. Through his lens, we can immerse ourselves in our favorite films, television shows, and novels and learn how unreliable narrators spin a tale to their advantage. If we pay attention, we can recognize how a narrator acts deceptively to pursue his goals, when a narrator is lying to himself, or when a narrator is unreliable through no fault of her own. 

Then comes the hard part. We must take the time to apply this analysis to the rhetoric of Trump and the media to identify how we're being manipulated as consumers of competing narrative views. Because everyone is spinning stories; some with a disregard for context, others with a contempt for indisputable facts. If we can pinpoint the unreliable narrators in our midst, then we can decide for ourselves who is telling the truth. It's time-consuming work; it should be easier to find facts. But this is the era we live in. The truth is out there. It may just be up to us to find it. 

 

May 31, 2017 /Tina Rapp
unreliable narrator, Trump era
~Writing~, ~Culture mesh~
2 Comments

  • ~Culture mesh~ 34
    • Feb 23, 2019 The divide, Hollywood style   Feb 23, 2019
    • Aug 30, 2018 Why John McCain’s loss feels personal Aug 30, 2018
    • Jul 31, 2018 What Gate 35X can teach us about chaotic times Jul 31, 2018
    • Jun 30, 2018 Is hate the new optimism in America? Jun 30, 2018
    • May 31, 2018 What we say when we don’t talk politics May 31, 2018
    • Apr 30, 2018 Jokes, lies, and tweets in the era of outrage Apr 30, 2018
    • Mar 31, 2018 The phantom thread that binds us Mar 31, 2018
    • Feb 28, 2018 Reverend Graham and the clear view Feb 28, 2018
    • Jan 31, 2018 Finding the end zone in the new America Jan 31, 2018
    • Dec 31, 2017 Fumbling my way into a new year Dec 31, 2017
    • Nov 30, 2017 Corralling the chaos without losing your mind Nov 30, 2017
    • Oct 25, 2017 #MeToo meets the military and it ain't pretty Oct 25, 2017
    • Sep 30, 2017 Oprah and the empathy question Sep 30, 2017
    • Aug 31, 2017 Trump and the ghost of Manny Ramirez Aug 31, 2017
    • Jul 26, 2017 Donald Trump, wonderful man Jul 26, 2017
    • May 31, 2017 The unreliable narrator in the age of Trump May 31, 2017
    • Apr 30, 2017 The love/hate business Apr 30, 2017
    • Mar 31, 2017 Them's fighting words Mar 31, 2017
    • Feb 25, 2017 Dancing while D.C. burns Feb 25, 2017
    • Jan 21, 2017 The audacity of hope, round two Jan 21, 2017
    • Dec 31, 2016 The intersection of hope Dec 31, 2016
    • Nov 30, 2016 Singing my way home Nov 30, 2016
    • Nov 9, 2016 The new American colossus Nov 9, 2016
    • Oct 31, 2016 On rigging an election Oct 31, 2016
    • Aug 31, 2016 When a colonoscopy feels like a day off Aug 31, 2016
    • Jul 25, 2016 It's your reality show, deal with it Jul 25, 2016
    • Apr 25, 2016 Lost and found in Bohemia Apr 25, 2016
    • Mar 22, 2016 A funny thing happened on the way to Facebook Mar 22, 2016
    • Feb 23, 2016 "The Revenant" as chick flick Feb 23, 2016
    • Jan 17, 2016 Citizen Trump: The sequel Jan 17, 2016
    • Nov 23, 2015 Watch your language, Mr. Speaker Nov 23, 2015
    • Sep 28, 2015 It's time to step away from the T-word Sep 28, 2015
    • Aug 30, 2015 Is there a human metric for the workplace? Aug 30, 2015
    • Aug 14, 2015 A day in the life of the New Hampshire primary Aug 14, 2015
  • ~Personal politics~ 3
    • Aug 30, 2018 Why John McCain’s loss feels personal Aug 30, 2018
    • Nov 30, 2017 Corralling the chaos without losing your mind Nov 30, 2017
    • Oct 25, 2017 #MeToo meets the military and it ain't pretty Oct 25, 2017
  • ~Writing~ 11
    • May 31, 2017 The unreliable narrator in the age of Trump May 31, 2017
    • Sep 29, 2016 Everyday triggers that writers can't resist Sep 29, 2016
    • Jun 30, 2016 The scent of cinnamon roses Jun 30, 2016
    • May 31, 2016 Hello, my American idol May 31, 2016
    • Dec 31, 2015 New year, new blog: Four simple steps Dec 31, 2015
    • Oct 31, 2015 Share don't tell: Can you crowdsource storytelling? Oct 31, 2015
    • Sep 14, 2015 Calling all poets: Digital wants you Sep 14, 2015
    • Jul 30, 2015 Eyes wide shut Jul 30, 2015
    • Jul 13, 2015 Rediscovering an endless summer Jul 13, 2015
    • Jun 30, 2015 Re-entry from utopia Jun 30, 2015
    • Jun 18, 2015 What they don't tell you about writing residencies Jun 18, 2015

© Tina Rapp 2015. Keyboard photo credit: Marie Yoho Dorsey. Other photo credits: Tina Rapp, unless otherwise noted.